Home / Cookies / Oatmeal Cream Pies Oatmeal Cream Pies $12.00 – $42.00Price range: $12.00 through $42.00 How Many? Choose an option3-pack – $12Half Dozen – $231 Dozen – $42Clear Product total Options total Grand total Pickup date and time options are based on current store availability. Minimum 2 days notice. Pick Up Date * Calendar Pick Up Time * Select a date first Oatmeal Cream Pies quantity Add to Cart Product Details Our seasonal fall favorite is back! Nothing says fall like our vanilla buttercream sandwiched between two perfect oatmeal cookies.