Artisan Cake Pops, Decorated Sugar, Italian & Traditional Cookies, Pastries, & Decorating Classes

High Quality


Customizable Desserts

100% Hand Made

Thanksgiving Order Menu!

Our 2022 Thanksgiving Order Menu is now up for orders! Pick ups will be between Friday, November 18th – Wednesday, November 23rd. Click the link below to purchase!

buffalo pie sugar cookies
Buffalo Pie Sugar Cookies!

Christmas Cookie Advent Calendars!

The cutest & yummiest way to count down to Christmas! Shop HERE to check out and purchase our Christmas Cookie Advent Calendars this year!

Shop Christmas Cookie Advent Calendars!
24 Individually Sealed Mini Holiday Sugar Cookies 1
24 Individually Sealed Mini Holiday Sugar Cookies

Step Out Buffalo Makers & Shakers Shopping Event!

Buffalo Cake Pops will be at the Step Out Buffalo Makers & Shakers Boozy Artisan Market the weekend after Thanksgiving! Visit us from 11am-5pm on Friday, November 25th, 10am-5pm on Saturday, November 26th, and 10am-3pm on Sunday, November 27th!

Christmas 2
Christmas Cake Pop Samplers


Cake Pops



Join our monthly newsletter

Receive exclusive offers and discounts from Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery by joining our email list.