Custom Cakes, Cookies, Cake Pops & Dessert Tables For Your Wedding

If you are looking for something unique and fun for your special day, Buffalo Cake Pops suggests our specialty, cake pops! They are great for traditional or themed weddings, can come in multiple flavors, and are always displayed just as you wish by us or your venue. We’d also be happy to complement your cake pops with a small layered cake to cut or cookie platters. We can even make you a cake pop wedding cake! And of course, more traditional wedding cakes are also available.

Wedding Dessert Display

Cake Pops

Traditional Flavors

$33/dozen for traditional flavors, can be done in any color scheme

White Wedding Cake + Vanilla Buttercream

Chocolate Cake + Chocolate Buttercream

Funfetti Cake + Vanilla Buttercream

Almond Cake + Cherry Vanilla Buttercream

Red Velvet Cake + Cream Cheese Frosting

Oreo Cake + Cream Cheese Frosting

Specialty Flavors

$36/dozen for specialty flavors, can be done in any color scheme

Graham Cracker Cake + Fluff (our S’mores flavor!)

Chocolate Guinness Stout Cake + Bailey’s Irish Cream Cheese Frosting

Carrot Cake + Cream Cheese Frosting

Lemon Cake + Lemon Poppyseed Buttercream

Chocolate Mocha Cake + Chocolate Buttercream

Pink Champagne Cake + Vanilla Buttercream

Banana Bread + Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting

Allergen Free Flavors


GLUTEN FREE Funfetti Cake

GLUTEN FREE Chocolate Cake

GLUTEN FREE Vanilla Cake

Chocolate VEGAN Cake (available in chocolate only, no color designs)

Not sure what design you want? Check out some past orders shown down below to get some cake pop wedding cake ideas. Or give us a call!

Fall Burgundy and Gold Wedding Cake Pop Cake
Fall Burgundy and Gold Wedding Cake Pop Cake

Bride and Groom cake pops
Bride and Groom cake pops

Wedding Cakes & Cupcakes

We specialize more in bite sized desserts, but definitely offer simple wedding cakes & cupcakes! Most couples choose a simple 6 inch round cutting cake to complement their dessert table.


Cutting Cake

starts at $45 for simple vanilla with vanilla buttercream


6in/8in round, serves ~40 – starts at $125
8in/10in round, ser5es ~65 – starts at $195


6in/8in/10in, serves ~80 – starts at $245


Regular Cupcakes

start at $36/dozen
+filling – $3/dozen

Mini Cupcakes

start at $30/dozen
+filling – $3/dozen

Cookies And Cookie Platters

Cookies were my first baked good love. An order of cookies from Buffalo Cake Pops for your dessert table gets every ounce of my love into your special day! A mix of traditional favorites and my grandma’s Italian cookie recipes will make your day unforgettable, I promise you!

Decorated Sugar Cookies: starts at $48/dozen

Pricing of decorated sugar cookies varies by size of cookie and level of detail of the design. Great for individually wrapped favors as well!

Italian: $20/lb (12-20 cookies/lb)

  • Cuccidatti
  • Italian Rainbow Cookies
  • Snowballs
  • Ricotta
  • Thumbprints
  • Chocolate Spice
Buffalove Wedding Cookies
Buffalove Wedding Cookies

Traditional: $18/lb (15-20 cookies/lb)

  • Chocolate chip
  • Peanut butter
  • Oatmeal raisin
  • Peanut Butter Blossoms (with Hershey kisses)
  • Lemon Poppyseed
  • Sugar M&M

Cookies will be boxed upon delivery, with additional costs for tray displays. We also offering individually wrapped sugar cookies starting at $3/dozen additional charge.